OurWord.See how people before you handled it.

Charles Darwin

Forestalled

Dated evidence, the case against yourself, and someone else to judge

Darwin's letters to Charles Lyell of 18, 25 and 26 June 1858; Darwin's Autobiography

Twenty years of work, and someone else wrote it down first. How do you claim what is yours without behaving badly?

Charles DarwinDated evidence, the case against yourself, and someone else to judge

What actually happened?

In June 1858 Darwin opened a packet from Alfred Russel Wallace in the Malay Archipelago. The essay inside set out almost exactly the theory he had been building, unpublished, for twenty years. He wrote to the geologist Charles Lyell that day: "So all my originality, whatever it may amount to, will be smashed." A week later he wrote again. Everything in Wallace's essay was in his own draft of 1844, but would rushing into print now be base? "I would far rather burn my whole book" than have anyone think so.

He had something with a date on it

He did not simply say he had thought of it first. The botanist Joseph Hooker had read his long 1844 draft some dozen years before. In September 1857 he had set the theory out in a letter to Asa Gray at Harvard. A date and a witness: that is evidence.

Send the idea early to one or two people you trust, and keep the dated email.

He made the case against himself first

Next day he sent a postscript, written, he said, "to make the case as strong as possible against myself". He put Wallace's objection in Wallace's mouth, admitted that losing years of priority was hard, and said that did not change what was just. Then he left it to Lyell and Hooker.

Before you claim credit, write the other side's best objection and show it to a third person.

Two names read together, then the book

On 1 July Lyell and Hooker had Wallace's essay, an extract from Darwin's old draft and the Gray letter read at the Linnean Society as a joint paper. Darwin recalled that it drew very little attention. He began writing in September and finished the Origin in thirteen months and ten days.

Settling who gets the credit is the start; what people remember is the finished book.

How do I use it today?

Where you are: You worked on something for years and someone else has produced it first, or it is about to go under another name. You want to claim it and fear looking petty.

Ask first: What do I hold that is dated and that a third person has seen? What is the other side's strongest objection?

Where it goes wrong: Reading it as a lesson in graceful surrender. Darwin gave nothing away; his name came first on the joint paper. He just did not grab. The evidence was old, the objection was his own, the ruling was someone else's. Without that dated draft none of it works.

Lines to keep

Write the hardest objection to your claim yourself.

A date and a witness make it evidence.

Credit settled, the book still has to be written.

Same situation, other people are asking

I said it and not one person took it seriously.Maybe I just don't have it.I did the work and somebody else got the credit.How many people would I actually need before this pays for itself?Nobody is looking at my work · all 13 questions →

If this one named what you are going through,

send it to someone who needs it, or keep it somewhere you will find it again.