Extraordinary Popular Delusions
Bought to sell, not to plant
Who is buying, and what for
Charles Mackay, Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds, 'The Tulipomania', from 'the more prudent began to see' to the defaults and the cancelled contracts
The buyers no longer wanted the flowers. When everyone is scrambling for something, what is its price actually resting on?
What actually happened?
Mackay describes a Holland where nobles, farmers, sailors, maid-servants and even chimney-sweeps dabbled in tulips, and small towns closed their deals in taverns, over tables set with vases of flowers in full bloom. Then, he writes, the more prudent began to see that it could not last. Rich people no longer bought tulips for their gardens, only to sell them on at double the price. Somebody was bound to lose badly in the end. As that thought spread, prices fell and never rose again.
The change was in the buyers
The turn Mackay records is not in the price but in who was buying. Early buyers wanted tulips for their gardens; later ones wanted only to sell to someone else. Once nobody wants the thing itself, the next buyer is all that holds the price up.
A flat nobody plans to live in, stock nobody plans to use: count the people lined up to take it off you.
A contract price counts on delivery day
Mackay records one deal. A agreed to buy ten Semper Augustus bulbs from B at four thousand florins each, six weeks later. B had the flowers ready on the day, but the price had fallen to three or four hundred, and A would neither pay the difference nor take the tulips.
A paper gain is yours only on the day someone actually hands over the money.
Everyone assumed it would last
Everyone, Mackay says, imagined the passion for tulips would last for ever, and that the rich of every country would send to Holland and pay whatever was asked. Everyone knew someone would lose in the end. Nobody counted themselves in.
Ask yourself: if I turn out to be the last buyer, would I still buy?
How do I use it today?
Where you are: everyone around you is buying the same thing, the price has multiplied in months, and you hold a little and wonder whether to add.
Ask first: how many of the buyers mean to keep it and use it? If nobody took it off my hands, what would it be worth?
Where it goes wrong: reading it as 'anything that rises fast is a bubble, so stay out'. The tulips were real flowers and the gardeners were real. What changed was the buyer, from someone who wanted a flower to someone who wanted the next buyer.
Lines to keep
When the buyer doesn't want it, the price hangs on the next one.
Someone loses in the end; nobody counts themselves in.
Same situation, other people are asking
Everyone agrees it's a good bet. Is that already in the price?It's obviously overheated. Why does it keep going up?Am I early, or am I just the last one in?Someone I know got rich on this and I can't sit still.Everyone is piling in · all 10 questions →If this one named what you are going through,
send it to someone who needs it, or keep it somewhere you will find it again.