Shun
Wealth, but no power
Give family everything except the hand that can hurt others
Sima Qian, Basic Annals of the Five Emperors; Mencius, Wan Zhang I
His brother tried to kill him more than once. Help a relative who wronged you, and how far?
What actually happened?
With the well filled in, Xiang thought Shun was dead and divided his things: the cattle and granaries to their parents, Shun's two wives and his zither to himself. He moved straight into Shun's house and sat playing the zither. Shun walked in. Xiang froze, plainly displeased, and said he had been sick at heart with missing him. Shun did not call the lie; he let it stand. Afterwards he served his father and cared for his brother more carefully than ever. Later, as emperor, he made Xiang a lord.
He came as a brother, so receive him as one
A disciple of Mencius asked: did Shun not know Xiang meant to kill him? Of course he knew, Mencius said. When Xiang was sad, Shun was sad; when Xiang was glad, so was he. Xiang came in the guise of a loving brother, and Shun took him in that guise.
The cousin who cheated you comes for the new year. At the table he is a guest; the old account waits.
Give the wealth in full
The disciple pressed: Shun exiled or executed other wicked men, yet gave the worst of them a fief. What had its people done? Mencius: a good man holds no hidden anger towards his brother. Love him and you want him honoured and rich.
If your brother cannot get by, money you can give, and the dignity that goes with it.
Give none of the power
Then Mencius added: Xiang could do nothing in his own fief. The emperor sent officials to govern it and passed only the taxes to Xiang, which is why some called it exile. He could not take it out on those people, and Shun saw him often.
Lend a relative money, by all means. The company seal, the bank passwords, the job of managing people: no.
How do I use it today?
Where you are: someone in your family wronged you badly, with an unpaid debt, a quiet sabotage or worse, and is back in your life. You cannot decide between breaking with him and carrying on.
Ask first: what can I give him, and what must never be put in his hands?
Where it goes wrong: reading it as 'forgive and prop up family whatever they do'. Shun gave Xiang income and rank and no say at all in governing; the people of the fief had the emperor's officials between them and him. That is where Mencius rests the defence. If you cannot tell those two apart, your generosity is paid for by someone else.
Lines to keep
Money and a title, yes. The knife, no.
No hidden anger, no grudge, and no power.
Kindness that someone else pays for is not kindness.
Same situation, other people are asking
He did it behind my back.I forgave it and I still can't get past it.I can't decide whether to stay.He took a piece out of me. Do I hit back?I was betrayed · all 8 questions →If this one named what you are going through,
send it to someone who needs it, or keep it somewhere you will find it again.