William James
This time doesn't count
Until a new habit has taken root, allow no exceptions
William James, The Principles of Psychology (1890), chapter IV, 'Habit'
You have made the resolution many times. Why does it always break on 'just this once'?
What actually happened?
In the chapter on habit in The Principles of Psychology (1890), William James recalled the drunken Rip Van Winkle of Jefferson's play, who excused every fresh lapse with 'I won't count this time!' James answered: "Well! he may not count it, and a kind Heaven may not count it; but it is being counted none the less." Down among the nerve cells, he wrote, the lapse was being stored up, ready for use against him when the next temptation came.
Start as hard as you can
The first maxim, which James took from the psychologist Alexander Bain: begin a new habit, or drop an old one, with as strong and decided an initiative as possible. Change your surroundings, make engagements that clash with the old way, pledge it publicly. Every day the breakdown is postponed makes it less likely.
The day you give up late-night snacks, empty the fridge and tell whoever you live with.
No exceptions until it has rooted
The second: never suffer an exception until the new habit is securely rooted. James compared each lapse to letting fall a ball of string you are carefully winding up. One slip undoes more than many turns will wind again. Continuity is what trains the nerves.
If you run every morning, run ten minutes indoors when it rains. Never let 'skip today' happen once.
Act on the resolution at once
The third: seize the very first chance to act on every resolution. Resolves work on the brain not when they are formed but when they turn into movement. A glow of feeling that fades without action is worse than a lost chance: it makes the next resolve harder to carry out.
Finish an article about sleeping earlier, then set tonight's alarm instead of bookmarking the page.
How do I use it today?
Where you are: You are trying to build or break a habit, and every attempt has died on 'just this once'.
Ask first: Has this habit actually rooted yet? How many times have I already opened this particular gap?
Where it goes wrong: Reading it as 'one slip and it is all over, so give up'. A dropped ball of string means more winding, not no string. On the same page James says the good side is counted too: people become experts by so many separate acts and hours of work. And the rule is for the early days, not for life.
Lines to keep
You may not count it. It is counted anyway.
Drop the ball of string once, and rewind many turns.
A resolution not acted on weakens the next one.
Same situation, other people are asking
I practice constantly and I'm not getting better.There are six things I want to fix and I'm fixing none of them.I go hard for a week and then touch nothing for a month.I set the same resolution every January and land in the same place.I want to change a habit · all 7 questions →If this one named what you are going through,
send it to someone who needs it, or keep it somewhere you will find it again.