Zigong
The ransom he would not take
A good deed done too cleanly can stop anyone else doing it
Lüshi Chunqiu, Xian Shi Lan, the chapter Cha Wei (Examining the Small), the passage on the law of Lu
Set the bar too high and the good deed stops. Why did nobody follow when you led the way?
What actually happened?
The state of Lu had a law. If a man of Lu had become a slave in another state and someone bought him back, the rescuer could claim the ransom from the treasury. Zigong ransomed a Lu man from one of the lords, came home and declined to take the money. Confucius said Zigong got this wrong. From now on, he said, nobody in Lu will ransom anyone. Taking the money would have cost Zigong nothing in virtue; refusing it meant others would stop ransoming people.
His deed became everyone else's price
Zigong was rich and did not need the money; refusing it looked nobler. But once the story spread, anyone who ransomed a man and then claimed the refund looked smaller than Zigong, and anyone who could not afford to refuse it was stuck. Easier not to ransom at all.
A manager who works weekends and never claims overtime leaves the team unable either to claim it or to skip it.
Zilu kept the ox
In the same passage Zilu pulled a drowning man out of the water. The man thanked him with an ox, and Zilu accepted it. Confucius said the people of Lu would now be sure to save the drowning. Taking the gift told everyone watching that it does not cost you to help.
Name the colleague who helped in the meeting and put it in the review, and next time people compete to help.
Watch the ordinary person behind you
The book files this under examining the small: Confucius saw from a small act how far its influence would run. Whether a deed was good is not only a question of your own virtue, but of the price it sets for the ordinary people who come after.
Before you set a rule, picture an ordinary person following it and ask whether they can keep it up.
How do I use it today?
Where you are: You led by example, working unpaid, never claiming, paying out of your own pocket, and instead of a good habit spreading, fewer people do it than before.
Ask first: What price does my example set for the ordinary person after me? If they copy it, do they lose out?
Where it goes wrong: Reading it as 'always get paid for doing good'. Confucius did not say Zigong should not have ransomed the man. He said the refund was there to be taken, so that the bar sits where an ordinary person can step over it.
Lines to keep
The example you set becomes everyone else's price.
Take the refund, and others will keep doing it.
Set the bar at sainthood and nobody comes in.
Same situation, other people are asking
The more rules I add, the more people route around them.Everyone is chasing the same thing. Where is nobody standing?Every hour is booked and one delay wrecks the week.The numbers look great. Is that skill or is it leverage?I'm managing it and it's getting worse · all 15 questions →If this one named what you are going through,
send it to someone who needs it, or keep it somewhere you will find it again.