Former NASA executive: current lunar landing plan is too complex, 2028 is fundamentally unrealistic
Doug Cooke argues that the lunar lander relies on unverified cryogenic propellant orbital transfer and a tall, narrow structure, each reducing mission success probability, while China's simplified plan more likely reaches the Moon first.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
Single lunar landing needs ten to twenty-plus launches—simply not credible
Cooke flatly states that the current Artemis architecture requires ten to twenty-plus rocket launches just to deliver the lunar lander to lunar orbit. ‘That's simply not credible to me.’ He notes that SLS and Orion are already proven, but NASA hasn't used SLS as originally designed. Instead, all complexity has been dumped into the lander and orbital refueling—opposite to the direction he and colleagues studied over thirty years. China's approach, by contrast, aligns more closely with those original research conclusions.
— Doug CookeThe lunar lander's cryogenic fuel transfer has never been validated at scale
Both contractor teams need to transfer large quantities of cryogenic propellant—liquid oxygen, methane, and others—in lunar orbit to give their landers enough thrust to leave orbit and reach the Moon. These fuels evaporate continuously, so the refueling spacecraft must be resupplied repeatedly and quickly before losses mount. Large-scale cryogenic fuel transfer has never been validated before. Cooke says he's been raising this since congressional testimony in 2019; now that landers are selected, the problem is more concrete.
— Doug CookeA lunar lander over 50 meters tall: like standing a pencil on the Moon
Cooke points out the new lander exceeds 50 meters—an elevator rises roughly 30 yards. Successful past landers—Apollo, prior robotic ones—were squat, low center of gravity, wide footprint: drop a foot into a crater and they stay upright. This tall, narrow design has extremely high center of gravity; lean beyond the footpads and it topples. ‘Like balancing a pencil upright on a table.’ The Moon's south pole is already jagged, shadowed, and its regolith properties remain poorly mapped.
— Doug CookeReturning to Apollo-style storable fuel design would actually work
Cooke's alternative—Plan B—abandons cryogenic fuel for storable propellants used in Apollo, paired with a shorter, wider lander matching the SLS cargo bay diameter. No reusability required, no new technology invented, just existing techniques. He concedes this approach has lower reuse potential and might not hit 2030, but within that timeframe it would actually be feasible.
— Doug CookeMore launches and critical operations means lower overall mission success rate
Cooke notes each critical operation—orbit insertion, fuel transfer, rendezvous, docking—carries its own success probability. Multiply them together: more operations mean lower overall success. He uses Artemis II as example: even a relatively simple mission demands near-perfect execution on every orbit correction. The current lunar architecture demands far more critical operations than before, further degrading overall mission success.
— Doug CookeHuman-scale Mars entry and landing is a technology humanity hasn't solved
Cooke admits that human-scale Mars Entry, Descent, and Landing (EDL) is a major unproven technology. Mars has a thinner atmosphere than Earth but still needs a heat shield; past robotic landers were much smaller and already pushed systems to their limits. A crewed landing vehicle is vastly larger. ‘This isn't a detail, and it's not a scale we've accomplished before.’
— Doug CookeNASA's engineering talent is hemorrhaging, decisions shift to approve-then-fix
Cooke says new administrator Jared Isaacman has acknowledged NASA's capabilities have declined. The problem is decision-making has become top-down—decide first, fix later—rather than grounded in solid engineering data. The so-called ‘commercial’ model also denied engineers the deep design participation they had during Space Shuttle and Space Station eras. This drove talented engineers out in last year's buyout wave. ‘They didn't see a path forward, so they left.’
— Doug CookeArtemis III rendezvous without docking is just wasting irreplaceable hardware
Cooke notes Artemis III plans Orion rendezvous with the lander, but he's heard little about ‘docking.’ Rendezvous itself will be verified in Artemis II with the upper stage. If Artemis III just repeats rendezvous without docking, ‘you're burning through precious hardware.’ The real leap—verifying cryogenic fuel transfer and absorbing the major probability hit—actually falls on the next phase, Artemis IV.
— Doug CookeIn their own words · checked verbatim
Well, I believe that, too. I don't think there's a chance of making 2028 without major changes that they don't have time to do.
Doug Cooke6:17
First in space means first, period.
Doug Cooke (paraphrasing Lyndon Johnson)19:21
The architecture itself is flawed and was flawed before they even selected the landers.
Doug Cooke23:19
It's like trying to stand a pencil on its end, basically.
Doug Cooke26:39
I believe it is. And you don't hear it talked about for some reason, but it's going to pretty much destroy any scientific data anywhere close to it, I think.
Doug Cooke30:48
We have squandered a 60-year head start in pioneering the space frontier to a nation that, without reason or provocation on our part, has chosen to become our nation's adversary.
Ken Ford (paraphrasing Mike Griffin)37:37
And when people tell me we're heading straight to Mars, it tells me we're not heading anywhere.
Ken Ford44:10
Figures
| Lunar lander height | over 50 meters | 26:39 |
| Lunar lander elevator height | approximately 30 yards | 26:39 |
| Artemis II human distance record | 252,756 miles | 4:12 |
| Human Mars mission round trip | 500 to 1000 days | 39:04 |
| SLS launches per Mars mission | 6 to 7 or more | 39:04 |
Glossary
- EDL (Entry, Descent, and Landing)
- The process of a spacecraft slowing through atmosphere and safely landing on a planetary surface.
- cryogenic fuel transfer
- Pumping extremely cold, volatile liquid propellant from one spacecraft to another in orbital space.
- new space / commercial
- Procurement model where NASA buys completed services from private companies rather than providing deep design oversight.
How to listen
Engineers, tech policy observers, and space enthusiasts interested in the US-China lunar race, aerospace engineering management, and major project architecture decisions.
The opening small talk about the guest's personal background, rowing, and collecting interests can be skipped without affecting understanding of the technical arguments.