Two Months of Documented Bell-Ringing—Possibly Just Satire
A retired officer meticulously documented his household bells ringing uncontrollably for two months, yet repeatedly wavered between "convinced it was not human" and "possibly a hoax"—later scholars believe this contradiction reveals the book was actually gentle satire of credulous spiritualists.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
A Poltergeist Case That Reads More Like an Elaborate Prank
On February 2, 1834, servant bells in Bealings House, Suffolk, England began ringing on their own—later becoming cited by paranormal believers as a 'well-documented poltergeist case.' But the hosts open by establishing the tone: this is not a terrifying ghost story, more like a ring-and-run prank with comedic overtones, though the question of whether it really happened has never been settled in nearly two centuries.
— Holly FreyThe Bells Escalated to Violently Simultaneous Ringing That Defied Explanation
Moore describes nine kitchen bells in a row, spaced about one foot apart, ten feet off the ground and twelve feet from the fire—he deliberately emphasizes these distances to rule out the possibility that heat from the fire caused the bell wires to move. He personally witnessed five bells shake violently at the same time, so intensely that he feared the bells would shake loose from their fixtures, and his son Edward James was present to witness the whole episode.
— Tracy V. WilsonA Reader's Letter Outlined Exactly How to Catch the Prankster
A reader signing himself "constant reader" offered Moore a solution: the next time the bells ring, lock everyone in the family in one room, secure all outside doors with keys removed, post watchers at every staircase, and conduct a thorough search of the house. He also mentioned that he himself can make multiple bells ring in seconds by pulling on the wires, and gave examples of another household that used the same method to discover the bells were being rung by a newly hired servant.
Moore's Own Experiments Couldn't Replicate What He Witnessed
Moore initially thought black birds fighting in a pear tree on the west wall might have disturbed the bell wires, but after witnessing the violent ringing himself, he concluded birds could not possibly produce such an effect. Using rope attached to a crank, he could only make the bells ring softly; using a hoe to pull multiple wires at once, he could make at most six bells ring, but the force fell far short of what he experienced—he admitted that even if he experimented for a whole year, he could not replicate that ringing.
— Edward MooreMoore Offered an Explanation So Incoherent It Explains Nothing
Moore attempted to provide a scientific explanation, proposing it might be some undiscovered law of electricity or galvanism activated by the combined effect of specific metal alloys and atmospheric conditions—but the passage is syntactically mangled with almost no main verbs. The hosts compare it to the rambling nonsense of Jim Ignatowski the taxi driver, and in the end it explains nothing.
— Holly FreyA Paranormal Researcher Systematically Dismantles Moore's Testimony
In 1899, paranormal researcher Frank Podmore published an article pointing out that Moore's testimony contradicted itself: on February 5 he wrote he was 'convinced it was not human,' on February 27 he said 'it could also be a hoax,' and days later switched back to 'convinced it was not of common man'—without ever explaining what changed his mind. More critically, Moore never specified who was actually in the house, never described what happened when the whole family was present at the same time, and explicitly refused the reader's suggested method of locking the doors to investigate.
— Frank PodmoreSkeptics Still Disagree About What Actually Happened
Based on this, Podmore argued that Moore was actually using the book to gently satirize people who believed in paranormal evidence too easily. But later researcher Trevor Hall countered that Moore was emotionally too invested in the bells to be reliable, and the real explanation was that a servant was playing a prank on him; in 1972, Daniel Cohen argued that the incoherence and pseudo-scientific gibberish were intentional satirical techniques, just so subtle that even today people cite it as a real paranormal case.
— Holly FreyIn their own words · checked verbatim
I am thoroughly convinced that the ringing is by no human agency. How, then, is it? I cannot say. A satisfactory solution is beyond the reach of my philosophy.
Edward Moore13:30
that I keep no monkey, that my house is not infested with rats
Edward Moore14:32
Lock all the outer doors of the house and take the keys, station a friend on each staircase, and with another friend make a thorough search of the house, locking every door and and taking out the key as the search proceeds.
I cannot help recommending you, as I have great respect for your name and character, to silence their tongues as well as your noisy inmates by the speedy application of toe and twine.
Major Moore never tells us of whom his household consisted and never describes a single occasion on which, when they were all gathered together in his presence, the bell ringing occurred.
Frank Podmore27:58
I did not in any way follow the advice therein offered.
Edward Moore27:58
I venture to suggest, as a plausible theory, that Major Moore, in homely phrase, was not such a fool as he looks, and that his book is a gentle satire on those who were ready on such evidence as that here offered to believe in supernormal or even unfamiliar agencies.
Frank Podmore29:00
the confusion seems deliberate rather than the result of bad writing.
Daniel Cohen30:02
Figures
| Kitchen bells: quantity and spacing | 9 bells, approximately 1 foot apart, 10 feet above the ground, 12 feet from the fire | 11:26 |
| System age and maintenance history | 28 years in use, with only one bell-wire repaired twice during that time | 12:27 |
| Moore's retirement age | 35 years old | 5:17 |
| Duration of disturbances | From February 2, 1834 to March 27, 1834, approximately two months | 23:50 |
| Moore's age at death | 77 years old (1848) | 25:56 |
Glossary
- poltergeist
- A mischievous or malevolent spirit that manifests through loud noises, moving objects, and general chaos, but rarely direct violence.
- Mysore Wars
- A series of 18th-century conflicts between the British East India Company and the kingdom of Mysore in India.
- Domesday Book
- An 11th-century comprehensive survey of English lands and property.
How to listen
Anyone interested in historical mysteries, the reliability of eyewitness testimony, or Victorian-era supernatural culture—those who want to see how firsthand accounts can be systematically dismantled by later scholars.
You can skip the lengthy technical description in the middle about the bell-wiring structure without losing the thread of the core dispute.