Cooking won't be replaced by AI: it's a reservation against the world of indirect experience
Professional cooking and shrinking home cooking are irreversible trends, but taste cannot be replicated by data—so the kitchen stove becomes the last place where people can keep direct, embodied presence in the world of concepts.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
The ‘firewood’in basics conceals a complete survival skillset
Li Yun points out that modern people struggle to understand why ancients put ‘firewood’ first in ‘firewood, rice, oil, salt’—today, lighting a stove is just turning a knob, but anciently, knowing which firewood catches easily was a skill even four- or five-year-olds had to master. Meng Qingyan adds his childhood camping experience: without alcohol blocks, using newspaper to kindle the firewood was exhausting, showing how the preliminary steps modern people skip cost the ancients tremendous effort.
— Li YunEven Zhou royal kitchens had full-time cloth washers
Li Yun describes from the Rites of Zhou the division of labor in royal kitchens—three thousand years ago, Zhou courts employed a position called ‘秘人’ (cloth keepers) solely to clean the cloth covering food. He uses this to show that the king's court was where civilization accumulated densest, where eating was most elaborate and meticulous, and thus where dietary practices left behind recordable traces, while ordinary people's eating habits remain obscure for want of documentation.
— Li YunHome cooking will shrink but professional cooking won't disappear
Meng Qingyan raises that food delivery platforms created ‘an unprecedented separation of eating from cooking in human history’—anciently, food and cooking costs consumed 70-90% of income, but that share has collapsed. Li Yun concludes: by pure efficiency of nutrition and satiation, home cooking ‘is a bad deal,’ so it will keep shrinking, but as long as people eat, cooking itself—social and professional cooking—won't vanish.
— Li Yun/Meng QingyanWhy people cook differs; there is no single answer
Meng Qingyan explains his motive is ‘瘫嘴’—food delivery tastes monotonous day after day, so he cooks to break the taste monotony and to recreate his parents' cooking from childhood. He notes that another friend, He Bi (何必), cooks for an opposite reason: He Bi's mind is typically scattered, but cooking requires his full attention—inattention burns the dish. They conclude: each person's reason for cooking differs, which is precisely how modern life requires people to find their own meaning.
— Meng QingyanWould robots taking over cooking completely be good?
Li Yun poses a hypothesis: if humanoid robots mastered all cooking skills and entirely replaced humans at cooking, would that be desirable? His answer is no—the more advanced AI becomes, the more human embodied ability and sensation gets ‘carved away,’ and people might end up living narrower lives. He presses further: AI can read and speak, but ‘can it recognize taste?’ Even if AI judges flavor, that judgment bears no necessary relation to whether ‘I’ myself can taste that flavor.
— Li YunSpice level quantifies, but what spice tastes like to each person doesn't
They discuss the limits of AI and data-driven cooking: temperature, knife thickness, salt by the gram can be precisely replicated, but once ‘spice’ is assigned a value of one to one hundred, different people feel completely different things eating the same spicy dish—Li Yun's spice tolerance clearly exceeds Meng Qingyan's. Meng extends this deeper: when he cooks saltier, friends still eat it and taste ‘heavy mouth,’ because ‘my cooking is me’—the cook brings mood and their day's state into the food, and that is precisely cooking's most unstandardizable part, as proved by a Tianjin small restaurant owner's remark: ‘if my mood is bad, maybe I didn't perform well.’
— Meng QingyanCooking is the reservation against the world of indirect experience
Meng Qingyan proposes: history is the future. From history's trend of labor specialization and delegated convenience, the process is irreversible, but cooking's meaning might lie precisely in preserving human embodied presence—the direct connection between person and world, nature, and time. He cites unfollowing travel influencers as an example: when video capture technology is so strong that visiting in person doesn't compare to the screen, this challenge to embodied presence becomes increasingly common, and cooking as the most accessible direct experience in daily life might become the smallest unit of resistance against this trend.
— Meng QingyanNeither embrace nor resist AI—it becomes infrastructure
Meng Qingyan responds to He Bi's earlier question whether he is a ‘embracer’ or ‘resister’: he is neither, because AI technology will, like DOS becoming Windows or handwriting becoming Word, gradually become life's default and infrastructure over time—this cannot be resisted. Meanwhile, he has followed many cooks' short videos, especially how avant-garde chefs' imaginative approaches often make him think ‘you can do it like that?,’ showing that AI and new tools can open more techniques and imagination for cooking, not just threaten embodied presence.
— Meng QingyanIn their own words · checked verbatim
I leaned on this for a while—where does this fuel come from? Um, do you have to go out and cut firewood? Um, what size should firewood be cut to so it burns easily? Actually, for the ancients, all these things were essential skills.
我靠了好一会儿 这个燃料从哪里来 嗯 要不要出门剪柴 嗯 剪柴剪成什么样的是容易烧着的 其实这些东西对于古人来讲 那都是一个必备的技能
Li Yun4:17
But you see, besides being lazy, I have this other thing—I'm pickish about taste. I'm someone who is both lazy and pickish about taste.
但是呢 我这人呢 除了懒之外呢 我还瘫嘴 就是一个又懒的人 又瘫嘴的人
Meng Qingyan23:20
But I think there's something really troublesome: now AI can recognize writing—it recognizes it well, speaks it well—but can it recognize taste?
但是我觉得 有一个很麻烦的东西 就是 现在AI会认字了 他把字认得挺好 说得挺好 味道他能认吗
Li Yun31:28
He wants you, in a sense, not to eat the food he made, but to know who the person cooking for you is—to understand what kind of person they really are.
他希望你某种意义上 你不是在吃他做的菜 而是你在认识 给你做菜一个人 到底是个什么样的人
Meng Qingyan35:32
I say I neither embrace nor resist. What's there to embrace or resist—as if your resistance could actually stop it?
我说我既不拥抱也不抵抗 我说这有啥可拥抱和抵抗的 就好像你抵抗他 就能抵抗得了一样
Meng Qingyan44:38
Glossary
- embodied presence
- Direct experience where the body participates and perceives the world, in contrast to indirect experience on screens.
How to listen
Listeners interested in whether AI will replace cooking, and readers who want to understand eating from historical and sociological perspectives.
You can skip the cooking chat at the start (0:00-4:17) and the knife-work and eating chat at the end (50:43-51:52) without losing the main argument.