Six-time Winter Olympic medalist: I excel at becoming a beginner again
Her softball dreams ended after a failed tryout. She switched to the unfamiliar sport of bobsled—not through inherited talent, but by repeatedly surrendering the identity of "I'm exceptional" and resetting to zero.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
Staking your entire life on a single identity means one tryout can collapse everything
Alana decided at age 9 that she would become an Olympic softball player, and played all the way through to setting records at GW University. But she describes that Olympic tryout as "the worst tryout of my life"—on her first at-bat, she swung and missed, and the ball sailed over the backstop. Because she had staked her entire identity on "I am a softball player," this single failure amounted to the complete collapse of her life plan; she sat in the car and cried with her father. Later, softball was dropped from the Olympic Games, cutting off any second chance entirely. What this reveals is: when an activity becomes a child's entire identity, its failure is no longer a setback—it becomes an existential crisis.
— Alana Meyers TaylorBefore switching sports, let your old identity die completely
From softball to bobsled, she didn't transplant her "softball player" identity directly onto the new sport; instead, she acknowledged that "this identity had to die," and redefined who she was. During this period she had no training goals but instead read books, considered attending medical school, and spent time with family—deliberately placing herself in a state of "identity void." She says that precisely because she knew nothing about bobsled (her only reference was the film Cool Runnings), she didn't carry the old pressure of "I must perform perfectly" into the new sport; instead, she could enter with the mindset of "let's see what happens."
— Alana Meyers TaylorPrice failure in advance, and you dare to charge ahead
The logic she used entering bobsled was this: I've already experienced the worst outcome—failing to make the Olympic team. So even if bobsled fails, it's just a repetition of known pain, not a fresh catastrophe. This kind of psychological accounting—"pre-paying" the worst-case scenario—let her approach a completely unfamiliar sport with the ease of "I have nothing left to lose." After her first ride in a bobsled, with all the violent shaking and roar throughout, her reaction wasn't to assess her talent; it was "I think I can do this again."
— Alana Meyers TaylorChildhood excellence blocks adult willingness to start over as a beginner
The host makes a counterintuitive observation: letting a child excel early at something seems good, but it can make them unwilling as adults to put themselves back in the "novice" position to try unfamiliar things. Alana confirms this has data support in sports—many athletes who won first place in their teens can't reach professional or Olympic levels as adults because they never learned how to adapt and grow; they were always naturally the best. By contrast, among Olympic medalists, the proportion who played multiple sports in childhood is unusually high, precisely because switching sports repeatedly forced them to cycle through being beginners.
— Alana Meyers TaylorEntering a field "white as snow" became an unexpected mission
She mentions that one reason she entered bobsled was that in 2002 Vanessa (pronounced Vanetta) Flowers became the first Black American to win gold, and because her own background was remarkably similar to Flowers', "I can do this too" became concrete and credible. But after joining the team, she discovered she was almost the only one—the bobsled community jokes to itself that it's "as white as snow," and she was even the first Black person some white teammates had ever met. This section places her personal athletic story and the sport's racial structure directly alongside each other, without dodging the tension.
— Alana Meyers TaylorBecoming the mother of a disabled child redefined what "achievement" means
She mentions that her older son has Down syndrome, and at every pediatric visit she's asked to check which developmental milestones he's reached, only to have to answer "not yet" repeatedly. This experience led her to completely transplant the athlete's definition of achievement (medals) onto parenting: success is no longer the result, but "whether I gave my best effort in preparation and whether I'm proud of the effort I invested"—regardless of where my child ultimately ends up or how things ultimately turn out.
— Alana Meyers TaylorThe real wager in "challenge accepted" is not winning, but having a story
She redefines "challenge accepted": not a bet on winning or losing, but a bet on "is it worth having a story?" This framework comes from her husband—faced with an opportunity, you either do it, and worst case you get a good story, or you don't do it, and you have nothing. Using this logic, she decided that after having her second child (both children are Deaf; her older son has Down syndrome), she would still pursue making the fifth Olympic Games, knowing she might not make the team again, but "I'll have a good story."
— Alana Meyers TaylorIn their own words · checked verbatim
it was objectively what I call the worst tryout in the history of tryouts
Alana Meyers Taylor14:27
this identity as me as softball player had to basically die. Like it was over.
Alana Meyers Taylor18:37
the worst thing that could happen has already happened. I didn't make an Olympic team.
Alana Meyers Taylor20:38
Really good at being a novice.
Alana Meyers Taylor25:51
I think in bobsled, we have a saying like, it's as white as the snow.
Alana Meyers Taylor27:56
I define my achievement by the work I put in.
Alana Meyers Taylor32:03
when you're faced with a challenge or you're faced with an opportunity, you have two options. You could either do it. And worst case scenario, you get a good story out of it or you don't even try.
Alana Meyers Taylor39:15
How to listen
Parents experiencing their child's single-focus interest derailed and feeling the world has collapsed, and adults transitioning away from a highly specialized identity who fear returning to novice status.
0:00-11:21 Information density is lower in the childhood personality and early experiences section; listeners eager to reach the core turning point can jump to 14:27, where the failed tryout section begins.