In the Bronze Age, 'sacker of cities' was the highest honor for a hero
Nearly every hero in Homer's epics engaged in piracy: Odysseus's first act after leaving Troy was to raid coastal cities, and the 'sacker of cities' was precisely the Bronze Age's highest praise for a hero.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
Piracy was not a sideshow, but the dark twin of trade
Kelder sets the tone at the outset: wherever valuable goods—including people—flow at sea, pirates appear. The more prosperous the trade, the wealthier the coasts, the more rampant the piracy; only when great powers establish secure sea lanes does piracy temporarily recede. This means the Bronze Age Mediterranean's booming trade network wasn't opposed to piracy—it was piracy's breeding ground, a single ecosystem where trade and raiding fed each other.
— Jorrit KelderThe earliest recorded piracy appears in a Hittite king's complaint
Hittite texts from around 1400 BCE, including what's known as the Maduwatta Complaint, record the earliest known piracy: a Hittite vassal king named Maduwatta allied with a Greek named Atarissiya to raid territories belonging to the Hittite king, including Cyprus. The name Atarissiya is almost certainly a Hittite rendering of 'Atreid'—the family designation of Agamemnon and Menelaus in Homer—marking the earliest appearance of Mycenaean Greeks in texts from other civilizations.
— Jorrit KelderThe pottery mistaken for a harvest scene depicts a pirate victory
The famous Harvester Vase was long interpreted as a harvest celebration with peasants parading pitchforks, but its original Italian excavators recognized it was a military column. Kelder endorses this reading—one rejected by mainstream archaeology for nearly a century: the pitchforks are tridents, the 'scale cloaks' are scale armor, and the figure scholars took for a drunken farmer was more likely a captive under guard. The entire scene shows not a harvest celebration but the triumphal return of a pirate fleet.
— Jorrit KelderA gold ring shows a 'hero' with trident hauling captive women
A Mycenaean gold ring unearthed in the Athenian Agora is labeled in the museum as 'Minotaur', but the design actually shows a man in a horned helmet holding a trident, leading two women with ropes around their wrists. Kelder argues that the trident was almost certainly the symbol of a raider, making this ring essentially a Bronze Age embodiment of the 'city-sacker hero' from Homer's epics.
— Jorrit KelderThe Trojan horse tale may originate in Egyptian siege deception
We tend to think of Mycenaeans as this era's fiercest maritime raiders, but Kelder argues this is an illusion created because only Greek accounts survived; records from other peoples were mostly lost. Egyptian general Yehuti (耶胡提) besieged Jaffa for ten years without taking it, then feigned retreat, leaving behind 'tribute' jars. The delighted Jaffa residents brought the jars into the city, only to find Egyptian soldiers hidden inside—nearly the prototype of the Trojan horse. This shows that raiding and deception were shared tactics across the eastern Mediterranean, not uniquely Greek heroic narratives.
— Jorrit KelderAs kings consolidated power, displaced nobles increasingly turned to piracy
Around 1300-1250 BCE, Mycenaean royal power reached its peak, with massive construction of citadel walls and coastal fortresses. On the surface, this looked like the state gaining control of the sea lanes. But Kelder points out this created a paradox: centralization meant local nobles lost territory, influence, and prestige. For these marginalized nobles to regain status, one of the most effective routes was to become a successful pirate leader and raise their own forces. State-building aimed at suppressing piracy may instead have generated more of it.
— Jorrit KelderPirates became deadly not through fleet size, but through new technologies
Kelder rejects the idea that late-period sea raiding was won through superfleets and numbers alone. Ugaritic texts show that only a few ships were needed to raid a city. The real turning point came around 1300 BCE with key maritime innovations: faster war galleys, rigging that allowed ships to sail upwind, and mast-mounted observation platforms. These technologies enabled small pirate groups to appear suddenly, withdraw at speed, and inflict destruction and panic far exceeding what came before—through tactical innovation, not fleet size.
— Jorrit KelderThe 'Sea Peoples' were not barbarian invaders, but network inhabitants
The Sea Peoples are often pictured as mysterious barbarian fleets appearing from nowhere, but Kelder argues that many so-called Sea Peoples likely came from the very regions they had been raiding—like Atarissiya and Maduwatta mentioned earlier. These were simultaneously victims and perpetrators; today's raided communities became tomorrow's raiders. Famine, plague, and the loss of status for nobles due to royal centralization pushed people who had originally lived by trade toward raiding instead. The late Bronze Age collapse emerges not as a stark conflict between civilization and barbarian invasion, but as a gray zone where allegiances and roles blurred.
— Jorrit KelderIn their own words · checked verbatim
So my hunch would be that these were people who were actually not too badly off. They had some, well, they didn't have money, but they had wealth and personal charisma, of course.
Jorrit Kelder15:33
And he basically does everything that his overlord, the Hittite king, does not want him to do.
Jorrit Kelder16:36
sometimes these raiders were actually themselves instruments in state formation.
Jorrit Kelder28:09
This is a hero, as they would call it. We probably look at it a bit differently, but in the late Bronze Age, again, piracy was not something that was considered necessarily abhorrent. This is what's part and parcel of what heroes, between brackets, did.
Jorrit Kelder41:33
one countermeasure may have led precisely to the thing that they were trying to stop. So piracy may have been actually sort of triggered by the consolidation of empires.
Jorrit Kelder56:00
Innovations like that may have been actually the major factor in making pirates all of a sudden much more efficient and much more of a problem in many ways rather than like the numerical scale.
Jorrit Kelder58:01
These were people who were, at the same time, both victims and perpetrators. They knew each other. They were, you know, a perpetrator could become a victim, a victim could become a perpetrator.
Jorrit Kelder1:02:09
Figures
| Mycenaean/Late Bronze Age span | c. 1600-1100 BCE | 4:04 |
| Maduwatta Complaint record | c. 1400 BCE | 18:40 |
| War galley earliest evidence | c. 1300 BCE | 12:23 |
| Mycenaean citadel wall expansion | c. 1250 BCE | 53:54 |
Glossary
- Sea Peoples
- Multiple ethnic groups harassing the East Mediterranean in the late Bronze Age; their identity and origins remain disputed.
- Linear B
- An early Greek syllabary used by Mycenaean Greeks, inscribed on clay tablets.
- Harvester Vase
- A Minoan relief vessel from Crete, traditionally read as depicting a harvest procession.
- privateering
- State-sanctioned piracy; raiding authorized by a government or ruler.
How to listen
Readers interested in ancient Greek history, Trojan War archaeology, Mediterranean piracy history, or Bronze Age archaeology
The opening chitchat about filming the Athenian Acropolis (0:00-3:00) can be skipped; the main content begins after 3 minutes.