If Shakespeare Died in That Plague, We Might Not Know His Name
When Shakespeare was 30, theaters shut for 18 months due to plague, his patron went bankrupt, and his contemporaries Marlowe and Greene were already dead—he is remembered largely because he survived, not because he showed early genius.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
The year he was born, plague had already killed a fifth of his neighbors.
Shakespeare's mother had already lost two children to childhood illnesses before becoming pregnant with him. During her pregnancy, English soldiers returning from France brought a major plague outbreak. He was born in April 1564, and the plague reached Stratford by July. The parish record notes: ‘the plague begins here’. That wave killed up to a fifth of the local population. Shakespeare's survival through infancy was itself a matter of luck.
— Rory LoughnaneMarriage at 18 and having three children before 25 closed off university and apprenticeship.
His father's business deteriorated around the time he would have graduated; university was unlikely anyway (only one peer attended Oxford or Cambridge). But marriage sealed his fate: he wed Anne Hathaway at 18 when she was already 26 and pregnant. Two years later they had twins. By his early 20s, he had three children to support. This was a completely different starting point from Marlowe, who was studying at Cambridge at the same time.
— Rory LoughnaneNo one thought him a genius in 1589—he was just a capable craftsman.
His early plays—Two Gentlemen of Verona, Arden of Faversham, Titus Andronicus—were not the works people would later emphasize when discussing Shakespeare. There is no evidence anyone in 1588–89 thought ‘this is the most outstanding writer of our age’. He resembled a journeyman experimenting across genres—comedy, history, tragedy—rather than a recognized talent.
— Rory LoughnanePlaywrights turned to English history because Elizabeth had no heir and future was uncertain.
Traditionally, English drama consisted of tragedies and comedies; history plays were rare. The turning point came when Elizabeth aged without an heir, leaving her successor uncertain, and society grew anxious about what would follow. Playwrights responded by consulting Holinshed's Chronicles, searching England's past kings for lessons about ‘English-style leadership’. Marlowe and Shakespeare were among the first to write history plays.
— Rory LoughnaneThe 'upstart crow' attack may have accused him of stealing other writers' scripts.
In 1592, A Groatsworth of Wit attacked Shakespeare as a ‘shake-scene’ and ‘upstart crow’. Scholars believe Thomas Nashe wrote this, impersonating the dying Robert Greene. The insult likely targeted Titus Andronicus—George Peele wrote the first 600 lines, and Shakespeare is believed to have completed the rest—implying he ‘took what belonged to others and benefited from it’. Class prejudice about his social origins mixed into the attack as well.
— Rory LoughnaneTheater closures lasting 18 months forced him to seek patronage through poetry.
Plague forced London theaters to shut for 18 months, eliminating Shakespeare's income from both acting and playwriting. He sought patronage from the young nobleman Henry Wriothesley, Earl of Southampton, and wrote Venus and Adonis. He unusually arranged for its publication and signed his own name—the first time ‘William Shakespeare’ appeared in print as an author. Yet Southampton himself was nearly bankrupt at the time.
— Rory LoughnaneHad he died in that plague, we would remember his name and little else.
Marlowe died at 29 from murder, leaving a literary legacy substantial enough to be fully traced. But if Shakespeare had died in a plague of the same era, the situation would be entirely different. Most of his early plays were published anonymously. Early works published in 1594 appeared without his name. He didn't sign his name as a playwright in print until 1597. Without a dramatic death to inspire later investigation, he would likely be remembered as having ‘written something outstanding’, yet almost no one would know who he was.
— Rory LoughnaneIn their own words · checked verbatim
an upstart crow beautified with our feathers that with his tiger's heart wrapped in a player's hide supposes he is as well able to bombast out a blank verse as the best of you
Dan Snow0:00
I would there were no age between 16 and 23, or that youth would sleep out the rest. For there is nothing in between but getting wenches with child, wronging the ancient tree, stealing, fighting.
Dan Snow2:08
up to maybe one in five in Stratford died during this period
Rory Loughnane7:24
I don't think there's any reason to imagine that anyone in 1588 or 1589 is saying this is the most extraordinary writer of our times.
Rory Loughnane24:55
one of the points the book tries to make repeatedly is that talent never arrives fully formed
Rory Loughnane43:53
I think he had real luck, but that's not to say it was entirely just good fortune.
Rory Loughnane44:53
Figures
| Total words in Shakespeare's complete works | approximately 785,000 | 32:18 |
| Number of plays Shakespeare wrote | approximately 43 | 32:18 |
| Ages at marriage | Shakespeare 18, Anne Hathaway 26 | 16:35 |
| Stratford plague death rate | up to one-fifth of the population | 7:24 |
| Quarto edition print run | approximately 700-800 copies | 39:40 |
Glossary
- upstart crow
- A 1592 insult from A Groatsworth of Wit accusing Shakespeare of appropriating other playwrights' work
- quarto
- An inexpensive printed edition of plays, sold for readers to buy or carry to the theater
- university wits
- Playwrights educated at Oxford and Cambridge who dominated early modern English drama
How to listen
People interested in the interplay of luck and structure in creators' early careers, Shakespeare history enthusiasts, those concerned with how the arts industry supports talent.
The section examining whether the school's teachers secretly practiced Catholicism has thin evidence and can be skipped (starting around 9:28).