The hard part of dementia care isn't the patient — it's the caregiver who gets ground down
The hard part of dementia care isn't the illness itself but the caregiver worn down day after day — caregiving turns a wife into a nurse, forces a millennial to quit her job; love is the starting point but not the support, and the system has yet to catch these families.
The video won't play here. Listen to the audio instead:
The argument · tap a timestamp to hear it
The care gap ends up pressed back onto every family
China has 323 million people over 60, 23% of the population; 35 million are disabled elders, but there are only about 500,000 eldercare workers. The supply gap has not been absorbed by the market or institutions, and the pressure mostly falls back on families and individuals. Alzheimer's is not a distant term: reports say China's patient count is nearly 30% of the world's, and the host estimates that on average one in every 20 Chinese families is affected — for the first generation of only children, this may be a reality their parents are approaching.
Dementia has no standard symptoms; the movies can't be trusted
After interviewing 34 families, the misunderstanding Tang Yong most wants to correct is this: there is no uniform image of a person with dementia. Society's imagination of dementia mostly comes from films, neighbors or hearsay; the professor's incontinence in Still Alice is only one form. He has met a tailor who, after dementia set in, still noticed stains on a visitor's clothes and taught people to remove them with orange peel; and a man disabled by a car accident who, when he could only hum Liuyang River, wore an expression of total focus. Dementia itself covers Alzheimer's, vascular dementia and other causes; each person's life imprint lingers in a different way, and caregiving cannot be performed from a script.
— Tang YongThe dementia village ideal is paid for by state nursing insurance
Most people take the Dutch dementia village Hogeweyk as the ideal answer: elders here stroll the supermarket and visit the café like residents, while staff play shopkeepers to keep up a normal atmosphere. But the details the host adds expose how hard it is to replicate — the 23 homes built in 2009 cost more than 18 million euros, of which 17.8 million was borne by the government, and residents' fees are also covered by long-term care-related systems. What Tang Yong saw in a low-income American nursing home was the opposite: elevators had to be locked to keep dementia patients from wandering off. The same disease, and the difference lies not in ideals but in the state's payment system.
Love isn't enough, and sacrifice will grind down the caregiver
The host sums up the caregiver's predicament precisely: many people swing back and forth between ‘I love my mom and dad so much’ and ‘I'm about to be crushed by my mom and dad’. Tang Yong says caregiving is not one-way help but a relationship; when a spouse has to learn to bathe, feed and handle emotions, the original equal partnership is overlaid by the relationship between nurse and patient. Long-term sacrifice is not a devotion to be romanticized: a daughter he interviewed in Guangzhou twenty years ago divorced and fell into severe depression after caring for her disabled father; the book also includes a millennial caregiver forced to quit her job by caregiving pressure. Love is the starting point, but without external resources and community support, the caregiver becomes a patient too.
— Tang YongThe more you see, the less certain eldercare becomes
After years of researching elder care, Tang Yong himself has no clear plan for his parents' old age. He is a first-generation only child, his parents are both 75 this year, and the more cases he sees the less certain he feels; his research assistant even said after every interview that the more families she saw, the less she knew how she would arrange things for her own parents. Families with multiple children have friction too: who does more, who pays less, or someone's rough caregiving gives the elder bedsores; only-child families lack manpower to share the load, and some who bring their parents to Shenzhen find rent, medical bills and nanny fees stacking up faster than pensions rise. An ideal model cannot be designed by a single child alone.
— Tang YongThe pain of dementia care is losing something every day
The biggest difference between dementia care and disability care is that the caregiver must repeatedly accept loss. Volunteering in Seattle, Tang Yong observed an elder who at first could paint blue lines on wet watercolor paper, but weeks later only dared to praise others and not put brush to paper; another elder's husband reported a new loss every week: his wife could not recognize the great-grandchild his daughter had just borne, and did not know where this child had come from. This day-after-day, irreversible downward slide drains a caregiver more than physical disability. The length of caregiving is not the repetition of hardship but a small goodbye faced every day.
— Tang YongLong-term care insurance is here, but it can't catch every elder
Long-term care insurance was piloted in Qingdao and Shanghai in 2016 and had spread to about 90 cities by around 2025, with the official pace set at universal coverage within the next two or three years. But Tang Yong cautions that long-term care insurance does not hand money to every elder; through unified assessment it mainly covers those with moderate to severe disability, paying for home nursing, meal delivery and other services; those with mild conditions may not qualify. The hardest part is mindset: putting parents in a nursing home is often equated with unfiliality in China, and elders feel like the grandfather in the interviews who said that after a month there his hair was nearly falling out. Tang Yong's judgment is that as younger generations age, the share who actively choose institutional care will rise, but the institutional gap will not disappear on its own.
— Tang YongIn their own words · checked verbatim
I love my mom and dad so much, and I'm about to be crushed by my mom and dad — I swing back and forth between these two feelings.
我非常的爱我的爸爸妈妈 和我快要被我的爸爸妈妈拖垮了 这两种情绪之间反复摇摆
So I think this caregiving is still a kind of relationship; in this relationship, the identities and emotions of both the caregiver and the cared-for, including the pace of their lives, all change enormously.
所以我想这个照护 应该还是一种关系吧 其实在这一段关系当中 我觉得照护和被照护者 他的身份情感 包括他的生活的步调 都会发生非常大的一些改变
Tang Yong36:31
It's like going down a slide — you're on the way down. So at that moment I thought, this kind of caregiving really is long.
就是坐滑滑梯 你是往下走的这个过程 所以这个时候 我在想这种照护 它确实是漫长的
Tang Yong37:31
I think although love is a very important foundation, it shouldn't be the whole condition of caregiving, right? It still needs some external resources, including some social support, and so on.
我觉得虽然爱 是非常重要的基础 但他应该不是 照护的全部的条件吧 他还是需要一些 外在的资源啊 包括一些社会的支持啊 等等
Tang Yong41:34
Although the more I see, the more cases I come into contact with, it doesn't actually mean I have a very complete or very perfect plan for my parents' old age. Precisely because I've seen so many different stories, it has actually left me with more confusion.
虽然看得越多 然后接触的案例越多 但其实并不意味着 我自己有了一个 就是非常圆满的 或者非常完满的 一个未来父母的 一个养老计划 正因为看到的 各种各样的故事非常多 反而其实让我有了 更多的一些困惑
Tang Yong46:39
His wife actually couldn't recognize the baby his daughter had borne, his little grandchild; he didn't know where this child had come from into their home.
就是他的太太竟然没有办法认出来 他女儿生的这个宝宝 就是他的小外孙 他不知道这从哪里来了一个这个小朋友来到他们家
Tang Yong53:41
He said, in that nursing home, I feel like after this one month my hair is nearly falling out.
他说我在那个养老院里 我感觉我这一个月我的头发都快掉光了
Tang Yong55:43
Figures
| China's population over 60 | 323 million, 23% of the total population | 0:00 |
| Number of eldercare workers nationwide | about 500,000 | 1:00 |
| Share of dementia cases that are Alzheimer's | about 40%-50% | 15:19 |
| Long-term care insurance pilots | piloted in Qingdao and Shanghai in 2016, spread to about 90 cities by 2025 | 1:01:49 |
Glossary
- Hogeweyk
- A closed community designed for people with severe dementia, where staff play residents to maintain a normal living atmosphere.
- The Soul of Care
- By Arthur Kleinman; argues that caregiving is not one-way help but a relationship.
- informal care
- Unpaid care provided by spouses, children and other family members, as distinct from hired nannies and nursing workers.
- long-term care insurance
- Social insurance that pays for nursing services for disabled and dementia patients, not a cash subsidy.
- wet-on-wet watercolor
- Painting on wet watercolor paper so colors bleed naturally, used as a non-pharmacological intervention for dementia patients.
How to listen
Urban only children born in the 80s and 90s, and anyone whose parents are starting to age while they have made no eldercare arrangements at all; also for those who want to understand the real gaps in the care market.